Prevention & Internal Controls

The Fraud Risk of Incentives and Performance Targets

Incentives and performance targets shape how organisations define and reward success. This fourth deep dive in the “Fraud Risk along the Employee Lifecycle” series examines the REWARD phase: performance evidence, independent approval, misleading metrics and the connection between genuine achievement and compensation.

Fraud Risk along the Employee Lifecycle — Part 4: REWARD

Performance targets translate organisational priorities into individual expectations. Bonuses, commissions and promotion decisions give those expectations practical consequences. Examining fraud risk therefore requires a close look at what counts as success, who records it, and how it becomes a reward.

From authority to incentives

The previous article, The Fraud Risk of Internal Role Changes, examined whether access rights and approval authority still match an employee’s actual responsibilities.

The REWARD phase adds another question:

What behaviour does the organisation encourage people to pursue with that authority?

For this lifecycle analysis, reward includes salary progression, variable compensation, commissions, promotion, recognition and access to desirable assignments. Performance pressure can also involve avoiding an adverse appraisal or protecting a position.

These mechanisms deserve attention wherever employees’ recorded achievements affect their own interests—or those of the people assessing them.

A useful starting point is to follow the complete sequence:

Business objective → performance measure → supporting evidence → approval → reward

Each step makes an assumption. The measure should represent the objective. The evidence should support the measure. The reviewer should be able to challenge it. The reward should reflect the result that was actually achieved.

Why targets belong in a fraud risk assessment

In financial statement auditing, PCAOB AS 2401 identifies incentive and pressure conditions as relevant to fraud risk. Its examples include compensation tied to aggressive financial targets and excessive pressure to achieve sales or profitability goals. These are risk factors to assess in context, rather than findings that misconduct has occurred. (PCAOB AS 2401, paragraph .07 and Appendix A.2)

Experimental research offers a complementary perspective. Schweitzer, Ordóñez and Douma found that participants given specific goals overstated their performance more often than participants instructed to do their best. The pattern appeared with and without financial rewards and was particularly pronounced when participants narrowly missed their goals. Most participants nevertheless did not overstate their performance. The study examined a laboratory task; it does not establish how frequently employees commit fraud in organisations. (Schweitzer, Ordóñez & Douma, 2004)

For practical assessment, this suggests examining the interaction between a target, the consequences of missing it, and the opportunity to influence the reported outcome.

The Fraud Triangle can help structure that discussion. It should not be used to label ambitious employees—or employees under pressure—as likely offenders.

When the measure becomes detached from the objective

Consider an organisation seeking sustainable customer relationships. It rewards employees for the number of new contracts recorded.

That measure may be useful. However, it leaves questions unanswered:

  • Did the customer genuinely agree to the contract?
  • Is the transaction eligible under the incentive rules?
  • Were unusual concessions or cancellation rights disclosed?
  • Does a subsequent cancellation affect the credited result?

An employee may improve the measured result through legitimate effort. A poorly designed measure may also encourage behaviour that technically satisfies the rules while undermining the business objective. Deliberately fabricating evidence or concealing material facts introduces a further concern.

Legitimate performance, metric gaming, policy breaches and suspected fraud require different assessments.

An investigation should establish which situation the evidence supports. A disappointing commercial outcome or a disputed interpretation of an incentive rule is insufficient on its own to establish deception.

Risk patterns across business functions

The following matrix applies these questions to common organisational situations. It is a practical review tool, not a validated fraud prediction model.

Reward arrangementPotential distortionWhat deserves examination
Commission based on new customers or contractsFictitious, duplicate or ineligible business is presented as qualifying performance.Customer identity, contractual evidence, eligibility and subsequent cancellations.
A substantial bonus becomes payable at a thresholdDates, classifications or estimates are deliberately altered to cross the threshold.Changes near the cut-off, their supporting evidence and who authorised them.
Utilisation or billable hours drive performance ratingsTime records overstate work performed or misclassify internal work as client work.Engagement records, deliverables, time-entry changes and billing adjustments.
Procurement rewards are based on reported savingsThe comparison baseline is manipulated or relevant costs are omitted.Baseline selection, total cost, changes in scope and supplier terms.
Managers are rewarded for low complaint or incident countsProblems are kept outside the reporting system or reclassified without justification.Intake records, classification changes and differences between reporting channels.
The reviewer shares in the same performance awardA second approval provides limited independent challenge.The reviewer’s incentives, access to evidence and escalation route.

None of these arrangements establishes wrongdoing. They identify where a review should connect the reward calculation to the underlying business activity.

A practical example: the contract that earned a bonus

The following example is fictional.

A technology services company pays quarterly sales bonuses once employees reach a specified value of eligible new contracts.

A salesperson enters several contracts shortly before quarter-end. The sales manager approves the entries and qualifies for a team bonus based on the same results. Finance calculates the payments correctly from the approved sales report.

During the following quarter, several contracts are cancelled. One customer disputes having accepted the recorded scope. Other transactions contain concessions that were absent from the approval material.

At this point, several explanations remain possible: legitimate cancellations, incomplete documentation, misunderstandings about eligibility, or deliberate misrepresentation.

The important control question is how the contracts became accepted evidence of performance.

Payroll can calculate a bonus accurately even when the data supporting entitlement is unreliable. Likewise, a manager’s approval may add little assurance if it relies on the same incomplete information and the manager benefits from the result.

A focused review would reconstruct the contractual position at the relevant date, identify what information was available to each decision-maker, and compare it with the applicable incentive rules. Subsequent cancellations would be assessed individually.

This separates three questions:

  1. Was the transaction genuine?
  2. Did it qualify for the reward?
  3. Was anyone knowingly misled about either point?

Designing rewards that can withstand scrutiny

The Financial Stability Board’s guidance for significant financial institutions connects compensation with conduct, risk management and customer outcomes. It also emphasises the involvement of HR and control functions in compensation design. Its sector-specific recommendations provide a useful reference; they are not universal employment rules for every business. (FSB, 2018, sections 1–2)

For the lifecycle review, the following questions translate the broader concern into concrete checks:

Review pointPractical question
Definition of achievementIs it clear which transactions, activities and outcomes qualify—and which do not?
Evidence qualityCan the reported result be traced to reliable records beyond the beneficiary’s own assertion?
Control over the dataWho can change dates, values, classifications or eligibility, and are significant changes reviewable?
Independent challengeCan someone without the same reward interest examine questionable results?
TimingWhat happens when cancellations, corrections or customer disputes emerge after the assessment?
Changes to the schemeAre rule versions, exceptions and approval decisions documented sufficiently to reconstruct an award?

Controls should be proportionate to the scheme. A modest award based on readily verifiable activity does not require the same review as a substantial payment driven by judgemental estimates.

Where deferral, reduction of unvested awards or recovery of paid compensation is contemplated, the organisation needs clear rules and a lawful basis. The availability and enforceability of these mechanisms depend on the relevant jurisdiction and contractual arrangements. The FSB guidance explicitly situates compensation adjustment within applicable frameworks. (FSB, 2018, section 2.2)

Make responsible conduct visible in reward decisions

A reward review should also consider the behaviour the organisation wants to encourage.

An employee who corrects an overstated result, identifies a control weakness or declines an unsuitable transaction may protect the organisation while reducing an immediate performance figure. An assessment focused exclusively on that figure can overlook the contribution.

The US Department of Justice’s Evaluation of Corporate Compliance Programs asks whether incentives support compliant behaviour, whether commercial targets can be achieved ethically, and whether positive contributions to compliance influence recognition and advancement. These are US prosecutorial evaluation considerations, rather than a global compensation code. (DOJ, September 2024, section II.C)

A practical application is to recognise evidenced conduct: the quality of a correction, the handling of a concern, or a documented improvement to a control.

Care is needed with apparently positive measures such as “zero incidents”. A low reported number cannot, by itself, distinguish effective prevention from weak detection or discouraged reporting.

Red flags that warrant a closer look

Useful review signals include:

  • Repeated adjustments that move reported performance just above an award threshold.
  • Unexplained differences between incentive reports and underlying operational records.
  • An unusual concentration of cancellations or credits after awards are calculated.
  • Significant eligibility exceptions without a documented rationale.
  • Reviewers who cannot explain what evidence they checked.
  • Changes to records after the assessment date without a clear audit trail.

These observations should initiate proportionate enquiry. Timing patterns may reflect seasonality; corrections may be legitimate; different systems may use different definitions.

The strength of a concern depends on the combination of evidence, its context and the explanations available.

What matters in a forensic review

A forensic examination needs to reconstruct the decision as it stood at the time.

EvidenceWhat it can help establish
Incentive plans and their applicable versionsThe rules governing eligibility and calculation.
Role assignments and award eligibility recordsWho could benefit, and in what capacity.
Contracts, delivery records, time records or other operational evidenceWhether the claimed achievement had a substantive basis.
Change histories and approval recordsWhat changed, who acted and when.
Relevant communicationsWhat participants knew, questioned or represented.
Award calculations, payments and later adjustmentsHow the reported result translated into a benefit.

The analysis should test explanations that support and contradict the initial concern. Receiving a benefit does not establish that its recipient created a false record or knew it was false.

Records should be obtained and preserved through authorised processes, with access limited to the purpose of the review.

Where REWARD fits in the lifecycle

The earlier phases establish identity, access and authority. REWARD examines how the organisation evaluates and recognises what people do within that environment.

The central test is whether a reward remains connected to a genuine, eligible and sufficiently evidenced achievement.

That requires cooperation between HR, the relevant business function and those responsible for financial and control assurance. Each sees a different part of the same decision.

The next phase, MANAGE, examines how leaders respond when targets conflict with controls, exceptions become routine, or employees raise concerns.

This article forms part of The Employee Lifecycle as a Lens for HR Fraud Risk. The lifecycle is an organising framework for practical analysis, rather than a predictive model of individual misconduct.

Related glossary concepts

Sources and references

Wie bewerten Sie diesen Beitrag?